Faith and Candor: John 20:19-29 (especially verse 25)
“Saint Thomas, the doubter,” we say. But to make Thomas a typical doubter is to miss the point of his character. There is no agnosticism about him, no hesitancy, no balancing of pros and cons, no sitting on the fence. He speaks right out.
When Jesus had proposed to go back to Judea in spite of the Jewish threat to his life, it was Thomas who had blurted out: “Let us go, too, and die with him.”
You see how he stripped the last wrapping from the menacing facts, how he drew the hard, practical consequence for his fellow disciples and himself: “Let us go, too, and die with him.”
He showed the same directness and simplicity at the Last Supper when Jesus’ discourse outran his disciples’ comprehension. Jesus had said: “You know the road where I am going.” “No we don’t,” said Thomas. “We don’t know where you are going, so how can we know which road to take?”
Thomas was just as open, just as direct, when it came to believing or disbelieving Jesus’ resurrection. He had been absent when Jesus first appeared in the upper room; the twelve gave him the news. “It’s no good,” he said, “I will not believe unless I put my finger into the prints of the nails.”
Here was a man who knew his own mind. He was not being perverse; he was not saying: “Unless I see and touch, I refuse to believe” as though he could believe perfectly well if he liked. He was saying: “There is no hope of my believing a thing like that unless my eyes and hands convince me. I’m sorry, but that’s the way I am.”
That was the sort of man Thomas was about believing and disbelieving. Jesus said that those who do not need evidence such as the exploring of wounds with a finger are blessed: “Happy are they who never saw me and yet have found faith.” Nevertheless, Jesus had mercy on Thomas. He acknowledged the honesty of his disbelief and he took extreme measures to meet and overcome it. “Reach your finger here; see my hands. Reach your hand here and put it into my side. Be unbelieving no longer, but believe.”
But Thomas had had enough. “My Lord and my God!” he said.
What Jesus did and said on that occasion shows his mercy to us all. He has salvation for both believers and disbelievers. Do you have the happy faith of Peter and John who rose and ran to the sepulchre at Mary Magdalene’s word? Who saw only the empty grave-clothes and yet believed? If you have such a faith, then to you belongs the blessing: “Happy are they who never saw me and yet have found faith.” But if you are a disbeliever like Thomas, then this is for you; this is Christ’s mercy to you: “Reach your finger here, see my hands. Reach your hand here and put it into my side. Be unbelieving no longer, but believe.”
Thomas was not praised for disbelieving. But still less would he have been praised if he had pretended to believe. And it would have been still worse, if he had tried to fool his own mind. He confessed his disbelief with all possible candor, and so Jesus came to his relief, as he had previously come to the relief of the other who cried: “Lord, I believe; help me in my unbelief.”
Our Christendom is spotted with pretended belief, insincere belief, until we do not know what we believe. Until, indeed, we lose the very sense of what believing is and of what the difference is between belief and disbelief.
Candor, like that of Thomas, is a rare virtue. If you want to know a person’s character, do not listen so much to his or her words or pay too much attention to her or his face while speaking to you. Look rather at the response in a person’s face when unaware of someone’s observation. Then you can often see people exactly as they are; see the self-conceit, the discontent, the greediness, and the ill will when it is the prevailing attitude of the person. Or, again, see the mysterious radiance which the grace of God pours upon the faces of the saints.
When a person begins to display conventional amiability towards you, he or she is not consciously deceiving you. In a way, it’s worse than that, for he is deceiving himself. He thinks he really holds all the amiable principles and attitudes which are displayed in his polite conversation. He thinks he is what he says. He does not know those deep grounds of belief or disbelief which inspire all his important actions and square with all his prevalent desires. You may know them better than he does just by watching his face in his unguarded moments.
I do not see myself. My neighbor sees my face, and God—God sees my heart. What does my neighbor see on my face? What is written there? Misplaced confidence in my own cleverness or humble trust in God? A closed concentration on my own pursuits or an open affection towards my neighbor? And when God looks into my heart, what does God perceive?
The only person I can really deceive is myself, for it is I alone who longs to be deceived. My neighbor does not want to be deceived; he or she wants to know me as I am. But I do not want to know myself as I am.
There is no question about it: We ought not to lie as much as we do, for in so doing, we corrupt the integrity of our minds to the extent that oftentimes we do not talk for the purpose of revealing either the truth of fact or of feeling; we talk to amuse, to flatter, to impress, to mislead.
As a consequence, we no longer know what we think, believe, or feel. In our discussions with other Christians, we express pious and orthodox sentiments, while on the street, we express cynical and worldly sentiments. Now, what are our sentiments? The pious sentiments are what we think we ought to believe; the cynical sentiments are what it would be amusing to believe; but neither is what we do believe.
Is it not possible for us to lay aside our pretensions and self-deceptions? Are there not at least those moments, perhaps at prayer, when we can reveal the nakedness of our spirits? “Oh my God,” I can pray, “I have scarcely believed. I have not lived out my beliefs, and so they are weak and vanishing. Of all the truth you have brought to your Church, so little means anything to me. And I have not deserved that it should be otherwise for I have been unfaithful. Yet, Oh God, you have not let me altogether disbelieve. If I said I disbelieved in you, my God, I should be a liar and ungrateful, for you have given me belief. I believe that you are in Jesus and in the Church of Jesus, though I have not exercised myself to know how. Teach me in your good time, Oh Lord, to enter more into the truth which you have revealed. But today, the faith you have given me is enough. I throw myself upon you, content to know that the faith you have given me is the presence and action of the Holy Spirit. I leave everything to you; you will not let me fail.”
If you deny your faith, you lie; and if you pretend that it is fuller than it is, you lie. Thomas told no lies. He believed some things, but he did not, at that time, believe Christ’s resurrection. Then Jesus gave him his body as proof. Christ’s body is still in the world; his body is his faithful people. Not every part of Christ’s body equally convinced Thomas; the parts that carried the prints of the crucifixion did. It is not every part of Christ’s body now that convinces us; it is the crucified parts—the saints who are marked with the signs of Christ’s sacrifice. There are such persons in the world, we have known them— persons whose words are like their faces, and whose faces are like their hearts, and their hearts are imprinted with the cross of Jesus. Jesus made them what they are; his death and resurrection are manifest in them.
May he who taught Thomas take hold of our groping hands and guide them to the prints of his saving wounds, to where they can be seen and felt in the lives of Christ’s true servants and saints.
In them we may acknowledge and glorify him alone who is worthy of all glory. To whom with the Father and the Holy Spirit be ascribed almighty dominion, majesty, and power henceforth and forever.
