Pietisten

Vol. XI, No. 1 Herald of Awakening and Spiritual Upbuilding Summer 1996

Paul Holmer Honored: Diagnostic Facts Elucidated

by Bruce Carlson

Professor Paul Holmer was honored recently for a distinguished life that has now spanned 80 years. When he was thirteen years old, he used the money he earned delivering newspapers to buy Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason. He never looked back.

As a student and teacher at the University of Minnesota and Yale, Paul Holmer has continued his insightful investigation into literature, philosophy, and Christianity. The 1996 meeting of the Midwest Division of the American Association of Religion, held at Luther Seminary, featured papers prepared by three of Dr. Holmer’s students. These students, now themselves active in academic life, described Holmer’s work and his influence on theology. Stanley Hauerwas (Duke), George Lindbeck (Yale), and Don Selliers (Emory) spoke of Holmer’s emphasis on the how, not the what, of theology, his sense of irony, and his connections with Socrates, Kierkegaard, and Wittgenstein.

Holmer began his response to these tributes by quoting Plato: “When the promise is so vast the feeling of incredulity creeps in.” He went on to mention three “diagnostic facts.” A diagnostic fact, he explained, is reasoned from, not to.

The first diagnostic fact is ignorance. When he was a graduate student at Yale, Holmer recalled, Bertrand Russell met with a few students and some faculty several nights a week for five weeks. The seminars were held in the elegant home of Professor Charles Hendel, chairman of the Yale Philosophy Department. Russell was not having a particularly easy time in the United States because of his radical views. He welcomed these seminars in which he was interested in discussing a revision of his Principia Mathematica. One evening, Holmer asked Russell about an aspect of Bishop Berkeley’s theory, to which Russell replied that he couldn’t remember. Holmer related that he wasn’t prepared for someone of Russell’s caliber to admit there was something he didn’t know. It is a diagnostic fact that there is a vast and limitless ignorance. It is a vision to be “in on this ignorance,” Holmer suggested.

The second diagnostic fact is the malleability of the will. The unpredictability of people is a source of great human danger; we need laws to help curb aberrant behavior.

The third diagnostic fact is that there is no immediate help for the human spirit. Help comes to the individual as he or she stands before God. This is said clearly and definitively by Søren Kierkegaard.

Professor Holmer said he appreciated the wisdom theme in philosophy. “There is a way to become wise and aware. Ihaven’t been able to package something. But getting in on these diagnostic facts... that is where wisdom lies. I have had to settle for a little cheap wisdom,” he said with a smile. “I just want to throw up my hands and say ‘take it or leave it.” ”

Holmer looked strong and confident. His arm gestures were slow, powerful, and effective. Every word he spoke was carefully chiseled out of his long Christian life of teaching and reflection. The audience included his wife Phyllis, his sister Joyce, approximately fifty former students of Dr. Holmer, and many other colleagues and friends, such as Drs. Soneson and Lindahl, long time North Park College Philosophy professors. People were deeply moved on this Saturday morning. It was a fine tribute and a thoughtful elucidation of Paul Holmer’s life and work.

In an afternoon session, Holmer acted as a respondent to a panel titled “Kierkegaard and Theology.” A dinner and luncheon were part of the festivities. It was also announced at these meetings that an annual lectureship has been established by the MacLaurin Institute of the University of Minnesota in honor of Paul Holmer. Professor Holmer has agreed to give the inaugural lecture himself in November, 1996.