Elder Lindahl’s “Church and State:” A Gut Reaction
Full tilt, Elder Lindahl took on that dragon of a subject, the Church in a totalitarian context. His observations are a reflection based on personal (a soldier in Germany in 1945) and academic (History at the Seminary) experience. He should be thanked for having enlivened your pages with so apt a subject.
Let me say right up front, however, that I am not sympathetic to Lindahl’s working hypothesis “...that the mainline German Christian Church supported the Third Reich, believing that the Christian Church and Hitler’s Aryan state had identical goals”—identical meaning, I take it, that they absorbed the Aryan philosophy of National Socialism to the extent that Hitler and God became one and the same thing. Tersely put, his facts do not support his case. From my limited university readings on modern Germany (1900-1945), none of the sources (the US historians on modern Germany, Raymond Sontag, Gordon Craig, and Gordon Zahn) advance Lindahl’s hypothesis. Rather, all three noted the “failure” of the German churches to speak out, except for a tiny minority. They cite Pastors Neimöller and Bonhoeffer as does Lindahl.
My reading of this period leads me to a somewhat different set of conclusions. The Lutheran Church was, for all intents and purposes, a national church. Whether it be Frederick the Great, Bismarck, or Hitler, the church was there to perform its function. And, lest we forget, Hitler came to power democratically, via one of the most liberal constitutions in Western Europe. His was no sinister coup d’état. Therefore, in his initial role as Chancellor, he was the continuation of a certain German theological tradition. I say this because Americans are great at the Monday morning quarterback exercise. We are all Joe Montanas; and Lindahl’s article appears to me to have this flavor.
His view of this period of German history appears to be seen through the prism of the Holocaust. If so, in a fundamental way, it is ex post facto reasoning. When the chips were down and the time came to attack National Socialism, with few exceptions, the fate of Jews was not a concern of any of the parties of the opposition. Witness the statements of Bonhoeffer and Neimöller. Their concern is with the corrupting philosophy of National Socialism only.
Was the opposition indifferent to the extermination of Jews? Were they unaware? I think the latter. Much has been said and written on when the extermination of the Jews became generally known to the various leaders outside the Nazi circle; but we still don’t know for certain. I don’t think that most of the German religious leaders, if any, knew anything really concrete, hence their silence. To have known and believed would have implied the capacity to think the unthinkable.
On this side of modern history, we are cynical enough to believe anything—our recent history has taught us this much. WW II, Vietnam, the civil rights movement, and a few other moral horrors like the Tuskegee Institute syphilis programme, have enlightened us. As seen from the time prior to the Third Reich, the only other moral, Western dilemma had been slavery. Even WW I posed no moral issue beyond the morality of war itself. Concentration camps, afterall, were internment camps that dated from the First World War, but only foreigners were interned in them.
Why then was there no moral outcry from Church leaders when the rounding up of Jews began? For the same reason, I think, that there had been no moral outcry, except by the Quakers, when Japanese Americans were rounded up and put in concentration camps. Yes, it will be argued, we did not exterminate Japanese Americans. But, let me advance a little hypothesis. Suppose that word began to trickle out that the interned Japanese were being murdered. Would there have been a moral outcry on the part of our religious leaders? I don’t think so, because few would have believed our government capable of so heinous an act. Such an accusation would have to be seen as vicious propaganda— America is not capable of this. Americans, too, would have been incapable of thinking the unthinkable.
The position of German Protestant and Catholic religious leaders must have been subject to the same logic. Hence their silence, for the most part, and their denunciation, where expressed, limited to the moral philosophy of National Socialism. Hitler, after all, had not attacked the non-Jew; and the German population had tangible proof that Hitler had immeasurably improved the average German’s standard of living.
Interestingly, Lindahl cites the 1934 Declaration of Bonhoeffer and Niemöller. In 1936, Pius XI issued an encyclical entitled “Mit Brenner Sorge,” deliberately written in German, which, in words very similar to the Barmen Declaration and perhaps inspired by it, he denounced the Aryan theology of National Socialism.
But Lindahl’s article raises a more fundamental attack. He implies that the German people accepted the God/Hitler Hitler/God analogy. If we accept the general theory on revolutions, be it the American, the French, or the Russian, one-third of populations are for, one-third are against, and one-third are hangers-on. Put another way, most individuals are not disturbed by the great moral crises that roll over humankind. Few Americans were touched by the Vietnam war and fewer still by the civil rights movement. Both were watched comfortably in front of the TV screen. Proust put it another way: “So-called immoral people feel moral indignation just as violently as others do, but about different subjects” Albertine Disparue, Vol. 2, p. 189. A morally vicious person may be morally vicious in one way and very religious in every other.
Another example from the Land of the Free and Home of the Brave: the massive lynching of Blacks—ironically during this same period. The good Southern Baptist and Methodist people who participated in this sinister business were no less God-fearing and religious before and after the lynchings. Given the wide extent of this practice, I wager that none lost any sleep over the lynchings either. More important, the Black religious leaders aside, my research does not reveal any major outcry from White religious leaders on this subject. The same argument applies to the silence of White leaders concerning the civil rights movement. Whites in general and White religious leaders, in particular, were singularly absent. And yet, the civil rights movement is now defined as the greatest moral event of our time.
I require no imagination whatsoever to see good German Protestants and Catholics working in extermination camps and not batting an eye, in the same way as their American brethren were able to lynch and then go to lunch, the former not being motivated in the least either by Hitler, Hitler’s Aryanism, or anything more tangible than “It is war, I’m a soldier, and it’s my job.” And, if I’m right in this assessment, the German has a more solid argument in his defense than his southern American counterpart, the similarities notwithstanding, because he, at least, was confronted by war.
Cornel West, Professor at Harvard, published a short story that has a bearing on this subject, entitled: “The Space Traders.” One day, aliens arrive from outer space and offer to pay the national debt in its entirety. The condition: every American Black will be handed over to them, no questions asked. West has the American religious and political leaders raise every moral issue and reference the pros and cons. Finally a decision is reached— every Black is handed over. Individuals are notoriously practical in times of crisis and do not require theological backstopping to prop or prompt them.
I think Lindahl has committed the error of attaching a heavy, moral and theological argument where none is really justified. Yes, it would have been better for us emotionally downstream to have seen the vast majority of German religious leaders and people publicly reject the sinister tenants of National Socialism. They didn’t; but that doesn’t mean that they accepted them either. Silence doesn’t mean consent. Ask God.
Finally, I want to comment on the remark by Lindahl that the Catholic Church did not excommunicate Hitler. I will give him the benefit of the doubt and assume that a slur of this magnitude was not intentional but, rather, a slip in scholarship. As of 1929, the German Catholic hierarchy placed an ipso facto ban of excommunication on all Catholics who joined the National Socialist party. Obviously that included Hitler.
The ban was lifted only after a bruising three-year battle between Eugenio Pacelli, the Vatican Secretary of State (future Pius XII), and the German hierarchy, following two flat refusals, by the latter, in 1931 and 1932. Pius XII’s argument was simple: not only would a ban of excommunication on a democratically elected head of state not fly, it would also split German Catholics. Rightly or wrongly, the argument won the day, the politically powerful Catholic Center Party accepted the Enabling Act leading to its demise on the German political scene. The Concordat was signed and each party went its separate way. That Concordat, by the way, continues to regulate the Vatican and the Federal Republic up to this moment; not one comma has been modified in the intervening period.
German Christians, Protestant and Catholic, deserve more understanding than they have received in this matter. My appreciation to the editors for promoting this important discussion. I hope it will continue.
